Arterial spin labeling-based Z-maps have high specificity and positive predictive value for neurodegenerative dementia compared to FDG-PET

David Fällmar, Sven Haller, Johan Lilja, Torsten Danfors, Lena Kilander, Nelleke Tolboom, Karl Egger, Elias Kellner, Philip M. Croon, Sander C.J. Verfaillie, Bart N.M. van Berckel, Rik Ossenkoppele, Frederik Barkhof, Elna Marie Larsson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Objective: Cerebral perfusion analysis based on arterial spin labeling (ASL) MRI has been proposed as an alternative to FDG-PET in patients with neurodegenerative disease. Z-maps show normal distribution values relating an image to a database of controls. They are routinely used for FDG-PET to demonstrate disease-specific patterns of hypometabolism at the individual level. This study aimed to compare the performance of Z-maps based on ASL to FDG-PET. Methods: Data were combined from two separate sites, each cohort consisting of patients with Alzheimer’s disease (n = 18 + 7), frontotemporal dementia (n = 12 + 8) and controls (n = 9 + 29). Subjects underwent pseudocontinuous ASL and FDG-PET. Z-maps were created for each subject and modality. Four experienced physicians visually assessed the 166 Z-maps in random order, blinded to modality and diagnosis. Results: Discrimination of patients versus controls using ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity (84%) and positive predictive value (80%), but significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps (53% vs. 96%, p < 0.001). Among true-positive cases, correct diagnoses were made in 76% (ASL) and 84% (FDG-PET) (p = 0.168). Conclusion: ASL-based Z-maps can be used for visual assessment of neurodegenerative dementia with high specificity and positive predictive value, but with inferior sensitivity compared to FDG-PET. Key points: • ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity and positive predictive value in neurodegenerative dementia. • ASL-based Z-maps had significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps. • FDG-PET might be reserved for ASL-negative cases where clinical suspicion persists. • Findings were similar at two study sites.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)4237-4246
Number of pages10
JournalEuropean Radiology
Volume27
Issue number10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2017

Cite this

Fällmar, David ; Haller, Sven ; Lilja, Johan ; Danfors, Torsten ; Kilander, Lena ; Tolboom, Nelleke ; Egger, Karl ; Kellner, Elias ; Croon, Philip M. ; Verfaillie, Sander C.J. ; van Berckel, Bart N.M. ; Ossenkoppele, Rik ; Barkhof, Frederik ; Larsson, Elna Marie. / Arterial spin labeling-based Z-maps have high specificity and positive predictive value for neurodegenerative dementia compared to FDG-PET. In: European Radiology. 2017 ; Vol. 27, No. 10. pp. 4237-4246.
@article{824c955d2a024d7c82616d72a28b9c16,
title = "Arterial spin labeling-based Z-maps have high specificity and positive predictive value for neurodegenerative dementia compared to FDG-PET",
abstract = "Objective: Cerebral perfusion analysis based on arterial spin labeling (ASL) MRI has been proposed as an alternative to FDG-PET in patients with neurodegenerative disease. Z-maps show normal distribution values relating an image to a database of controls. They are routinely used for FDG-PET to demonstrate disease-specific patterns of hypometabolism at the individual level. This study aimed to compare the performance of Z-maps based on ASL to FDG-PET. Methods: Data were combined from two separate sites, each cohort consisting of patients with Alzheimer’s disease (n = 18 + 7), frontotemporal dementia (n = 12 + 8) and controls (n = 9 + 29). Subjects underwent pseudocontinuous ASL and FDG-PET. Z-maps were created for each subject and modality. Four experienced physicians visually assessed the 166 Z-maps in random order, blinded to modality and diagnosis. Results: Discrimination of patients versus controls using ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity (84{\%}) and positive predictive value (80{\%}), but significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps (53{\%} vs. 96{\%}, p < 0.001). Among true-positive cases, correct diagnoses were made in 76{\%} (ASL) and 84{\%} (FDG-PET) (p = 0.168). Conclusion: ASL-based Z-maps can be used for visual assessment of neurodegenerative dementia with high specificity and positive predictive value, but with inferior sensitivity compared to FDG-PET. Key points: • ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity and positive predictive value in neurodegenerative dementia. • ASL-based Z-maps had significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps. • FDG-PET might be reserved for ASL-negative cases where clinical suspicion persists. • Findings were similar at two study sites.",
keywords = "18F-FDG, Arterial spin labeling MRI, Dementia, Neurodegenerative, Visual assessment",
author = "David F{\"a}llmar and Sven Haller and Johan Lilja and Torsten Danfors and Lena Kilander and Nelleke Tolboom and Karl Egger and Elias Kellner and Croon, {Philip M.} and Verfaillie, {Sander C.J.} and {van Berckel}, {Bart N.M.} and Rik Ossenkoppele and Frederik Barkhof and Larsson, {Elna Marie}",
year = "2017",
month = "10",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s00330-017-4784-1",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "4237--4246",
journal = "European Radiology",
issn = "0938-7994",
publisher = "Springer Verlag",
number = "10",

}

Arterial spin labeling-based Z-maps have high specificity and positive predictive value for neurodegenerative dementia compared to FDG-PET. / Fällmar, David; Haller, Sven; Lilja, Johan; Danfors, Torsten; Kilander, Lena; Tolboom, Nelleke; Egger, Karl; Kellner, Elias; Croon, Philip M.; Verfaillie, Sander C.J.; van Berckel, Bart N.M.; Ossenkoppele, Rik; Barkhof, Frederik; Larsson, Elna Marie.

In: European Radiology, Vol. 27, No. 10, 01.10.2017, p. 4237-4246.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Arterial spin labeling-based Z-maps have high specificity and positive predictive value for neurodegenerative dementia compared to FDG-PET

AU - Fällmar, David

AU - Haller, Sven

AU - Lilja, Johan

AU - Danfors, Torsten

AU - Kilander, Lena

AU - Tolboom, Nelleke

AU - Egger, Karl

AU - Kellner, Elias

AU - Croon, Philip M.

AU - Verfaillie, Sander C.J.

AU - van Berckel, Bart N.M.

AU - Ossenkoppele, Rik

AU - Barkhof, Frederik

AU - Larsson, Elna Marie

PY - 2017/10/1

Y1 - 2017/10/1

N2 - Objective: Cerebral perfusion analysis based on arterial spin labeling (ASL) MRI has been proposed as an alternative to FDG-PET in patients with neurodegenerative disease. Z-maps show normal distribution values relating an image to a database of controls. They are routinely used for FDG-PET to demonstrate disease-specific patterns of hypometabolism at the individual level. This study aimed to compare the performance of Z-maps based on ASL to FDG-PET. Methods: Data were combined from two separate sites, each cohort consisting of patients with Alzheimer’s disease (n = 18 + 7), frontotemporal dementia (n = 12 + 8) and controls (n = 9 + 29). Subjects underwent pseudocontinuous ASL and FDG-PET. Z-maps were created for each subject and modality. Four experienced physicians visually assessed the 166 Z-maps in random order, blinded to modality and diagnosis. Results: Discrimination of patients versus controls using ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity (84%) and positive predictive value (80%), but significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps (53% vs. 96%, p < 0.001). Among true-positive cases, correct diagnoses were made in 76% (ASL) and 84% (FDG-PET) (p = 0.168). Conclusion: ASL-based Z-maps can be used for visual assessment of neurodegenerative dementia with high specificity and positive predictive value, but with inferior sensitivity compared to FDG-PET. Key points: • ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity and positive predictive value in neurodegenerative dementia. • ASL-based Z-maps had significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps. • FDG-PET might be reserved for ASL-negative cases where clinical suspicion persists. • Findings were similar at two study sites.

AB - Objective: Cerebral perfusion analysis based on arterial spin labeling (ASL) MRI has been proposed as an alternative to FDG-PET in patients with neurodegenerative disease. Z-maps show normal distribution values relating an image to a database of controls. They are routinely used for FDG-PET to demonstrate disease-specific patterns of hypometabolism at the individual level. This study aimed to compare the performance of Z-maps based on ASL to FDG-PET. Methods: Data were combined from two separate sites, each cohort consisting of patients with Alzheimer’s disease (n = 18 + 7), frontotemporal dementia (n = 12 + 8) and controls (n = 9 + 29). Subjects underwent pseudocontinuous ASL and FDG-PET. Z-maps were created for each subject and modality. Four experienced physicians visually assessed the 166 Z-maps in random order, blinded to modality and diagnosis. Results: Discrimination of patients versus controls using ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity (84%) and positive predictive value (80%), but significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps (53% vs. 96%, p < 0.001). Among true-positive cases, correct diagnoses were made in 76% (ASL) and 84% (FDG-PET) (p = 0.168). Conclusion: ASL-based Z-maps can be used for visual assessment of neurodegenerative dementia with high specificity and positive predictive value, but with inferior sensitivity compared to FDG-PET. Key points: • ASL-based Z-maps yielded high specificity and positive predictive value in neurodegenerative dementia. • ASL-based Z-maps had significantly lower sensitivity compared to FDG-PET-based Z-maps. • FDG-PET might be reserved for ASL-negative cases where clinical suspicion persists. • Findings were similar at two study sites.

KW - 18F-FDG

KW - Arterial spin labeling MRI

KW - Dementia

KW - Neurodegenerative

KW - Visual assessment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85016998298&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s00330-017-4784-1

DO - 10.1007/s00330-017-4784-1

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 4237

EP - 4246

JO - European Radiology

JF - European Radiology

SN - 0938-7994

IS - 10

ER -