Abstract
Background & Aims: HBV coinfection is common among people living with HIV (PLWH) and is the most important cause of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). While risk prediction tools for HCC have been validated in patients with HBV monoinfection, they have not been evaluated in PLWH. Thus, we performed an external validation of PAGE-B in people with HIV/HBV coinfection. Methods: We included data on PLWH from four European cohorts who were positive for HBsAg and did not have HCC before starting tenofovir. We estimated the predictive performance of PAGE-B for HCC occurrence over 15 years in patients receiving tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy. Model discrimination was assessed after multiple imputation using Cox regression with the prognostic index as a covariate, and by calculating Harrell's c-index. Calibration was assessed by comparing our cumulative incidence with the PAGE-B derivation study using Kaplan-Meier curves. Results: In total, 2,963 individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection on tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy were included. PAGE-B was <10 in 26.5%, 10–17 in 57.7%, and ≥18 in 15.7% of patients. Within a median follow-up of 9.6 years, HCC occurred in 68 individuals (2.58/1,000 patient-years, 95% CI 2.03–3.27). The regression slope of the prognostic index for developing HCC within 15 years was 0.93 (95% CI 0.61–1.25), and the pooled c-index was 0.77 (range 0.73–0.80), both indicating good model discrimination. The cumulative incidence of HCC was lower in our study compared to the derivation study. A PAGE-B cut-off of <10 had a negative predictive value of 99.4% for the development of HCC within 5 years. Restricting efforts to individuals with a PAGE-B of ≥10 would spare unnecessary HCC screening in 27% of individuals. Conclusions: For individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection, PAGE-B is a valid tool to determine the need for HCC screening. Impact and implications: Chronic HBV infection is the most important cause of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) among people living with HIV. Valid risk prediction may enable better targeting of HCC screening efforts to high-risk individuals. We aimed to validate PAGE-B, a risk prediction tool that is based on age, sex, and platelets, in 2,963 individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection who received tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy. In the present study, PAGE-B showed good discrimination, adequate calibration, and a cut-off of <10 had a negative predictive value of 99.4% for the development of HCC within 5 years. These results indicate that PAGE-B is a simple and valid risk prediction tool to determine the need for HCC screening among people living with HIV and HBV.
Original language | English |
---|---|
Pages (from-to) | 947-957 |
Number of pages | 11 |
Journal | Journal of Hepatology |
Volume | 78 |
Issue number | 5 |
Early online date | 2023 |
DOIs | |
Publication status | Published - May 2023 |
Access to Document
Other files and links
Cite this
- APA
- Author
- BIBTEX
- Harvard
- Standard
- RIS
- Vancouver
}
External validation of the PAGE-B score for HCC risk prediction in people living with HIV/HBV coinfection. / the Swiss HIV Cohort Study; EuroSIDA; ATHENA Observational Cohort Study et al.
In: Journal of Hepatology, Vol. 78, No. 5, 05.2023, p. 947-957.Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › Academic › peer-review
TY - JOUR
T1 - External validation of the PAGE-B score for HCC risk prediction in people living with HIV/HBV coinfection
AU - Surial, Bernard
AU - Ramírez Mena, Adrià
AU - Roumet, Marie
AU - Limacher, Andreas
AU - Smit, Colette
AU - Leleux, Olivier
AU - Mocroft, Amanda
AU - van der Valk, Marc
AU - Bonnet, Fabrice
AU - Peters, Lars
AU - Rockstroh, J. rgen K.
AU - Günthard, Huldrych F.
AU - Berzigotti, Annalisa
AU - Rauch, Andri
AU - Wandeler, Gilles
AU - the Swiss HIV Cohort Study
AU - Abela, I.
AU - Aebi-Popp, K.
AU - Anagnostopoulos, A.
AU - Battegay, M.
AU - Bernasconi, E.
AU - Braun, D. L.
AU - Bucher, H. C.
AU - Calmy, A.
AU - Cavassini, M.
AU - Ciuffi, A.
AU - Dollenmaier, G.
AU - Egger, M.
AU - Elzi, L.
AU - Fehr, J.
AU - Fellay, J.
AU - Furrer, H.
AU - Fux, C. A.
AU - Günthard, H. F.
AU - Hachfeld, A.
AU - Haerry, D.
AU - Hasse, B.
AU - Hirsch, H. H.
AU - Hoffmann, M.
AU - Hösli, I.
AU - Huber, M.
AU - Jackson-Perry, D.
AU - Kahlert, C. R.
AU - Kaiser, L.
AU - Keiser, O.
AU - Klimkait, T.
AU - Kouyos, R. D.
AU - Kovari, H.
AU - Kusejko, K.
AU - Labhardt, N.
AU - Leuzinger, K.
AU - de Tejada B, Martinez
AU - Marzolini, C.
AU - Metzner, K. J.
AU - Müller, N.
AU - Nemeth, J.
AU - Nicca, D.
AU - Notter, J.
AU - Paioni, P.
AU - Pantaleo, G.
AU - Perreau, M.
AU - Rauch, A.
AU - Salazar-Vizcaya, L.
AU - Schmid, P.
AU - Speck, R.
AU - Stöckle, M.
AU - Tarr, P.
AU - Trkola, A.
AU - Wandeler, G.
AU - EuroSIDA
AU - Weisser, M.
AU - Yerly, S.
AU - ATHENA Observational Cohort Study
AU - van der Valk, M.
AU - Geerlings, S. E.
AU - Goorhuis, A.
AU - Harris, V. C.
AU - Hovius, J. W.
AU - Lempkes, B.
AU - Nellen, F. J. B.
AU - van der Poll, T.
AU - Prins, J. M.
AU - Spoorenberg, V.
AU - van Vugt, M.
AU - Wiersinga, W. J.
AU - Wit, F. W. M. N.
AU - Bruins, C.
AU - van Eden, J.
AU - Hylkema-van den Bout, I. J.
AU - van Hes, A. M. H.
AU - Pijnappel, F. J. J.
AU - Smalhout, S. Y.
AU - Weijsenfeld, A. M.
AU - Back, N. K. T.
AU - Berkhout, B.
AU - Cornelissen, M. T. E.
AU - van Houdt, R.
AU - Jonges, M.
AU - Jurriaans, S.
AU - Schinkel, C. J.
AU - Wolthers, K. C.
AU - Zaaijer, H. L.
AU - Peters, E. J. G.
AU - van Agtmael, M. A.
AU - Autar, R. S.
AU - Bomers, M.
AU - Sigaloff, K. C. E.
AU - Heitmuller, M.
AU - Laan, L. M.
AU - van den Berge, M.
AU - Stegeman, A.
AU - Baas, S.
AU - Hage de Looff, L.
AU - van Arkel, A.
AU - Stohr, J.
AU - Wintermans, B.
AU - Pronk, M. J. H.
AU - Ammerlaan, H. S. M.
AU - de Munnik, E. S.
AU - Deiman, B.
AU - Jansz, A. R.
AU - Scharnhorst, V.
AU - Tjhie, J.
AU - Wegdam, M. C. A.
AU - van Eeden, A.
AU - Hoornenborg, E.
AU - Nellen, J.
AU - Alers, W.
AU - Elsenburg, L. J. M.
AU - Nobel, H.
AU - van Kasteren, M. E. E.
AU - Berrevoets, M. A. H.
AU - Brouwer, A. E.
AU - de Kruijf-van de Wiel, B. A. F. M.
AU - Adams, A.
AU - Rijkevoorsel, M. Pawels-van
AU - Buiting, A. G. M.
AU - Murck, J. L.
AU - Rokx, C.
AU - Anas, A. A.
AU - Bax, H. I.
AU - van Gorp, E. C. M.
AU - de Mendonça Melo, M.
AU - van Nood, E.
AU - Nouwen, J. L.
AU - Rijnders, B. J. A.
AU - Schurink, C. A. M.
AU - Slobbe, L.
AU - de Vries-Sluijs, T. E. M. S.
AU - Bassant, N.
AU - van Beek, J. E. A.
AU - Vriesde, M.
AU - van Zonneveld, L. M.
AU - de Groot, J.
AU - van Kampen, J. J. A.
AU - Koopmans, M. P. G.
AU - Rahamat-Langendoen, J. C.
AU - Branger, J.
AU - Douma, R. A.
AU - Cents-Bosma, A. S.
AU - Duijf-van de Ven, C. J. H. M.
AU - Schippers, E. F.
AU - van Nieuwkoop, C.
AU - Geilings, J.
AU - van Winden, S.
AU - van der Hut, G.
AU - van Burgel, N. D.
AU - Leyten, E. M. S.
AU - Gelinck, L. B. S.
AU - Mollema, F.
AU - Wildenbeest, G. S.
AU - Nguyen, T.
AU - Groeneveld, P. H. P.
AU - Bouwhuis, J. W.
AU - Lammers, A. J. J.
AU - van Hulzen, A. G. W.
AU - Kraan, S.
AU - Kruiper, M. S. M.
AU - van der Bliek, G. L.
AU - Bor, P. C. J.
AU - Debast, S. B.
AU - Wagenvoort, G. H. J.
AU - Roukens, A. H. E.
AU - de Boer, M. G. J.
AU - Jolink, H.
AU - Lambregts, M. M. C.
AU - Scheper, H.
AU - Dorama, W.
AU - van Holten, N.
AU - Claas, E. C. J.
AU - Wessels, E.
AU - Hollander, J. G. den
AU - el Moussaoui, R.
AU - Pogany, K.
AU - Brouwer, C. J.
AU - Heida-Peters, D.
AU - Mulder, E.
AU - Smit, J. V.
AU - Struik-Kalkman, D.
AU - van Niekerk, T.
AU - Pontesilli, O.
AU - van Tienen, C.
AU - Lowe, S. H.
AU - Lashof, A. M. L. Oude
AU - Posthouwer, D.
AU - van Wolfswinkel, M. E.
AU - Ackens, R. P.
AU - Burgers, K.
AU - Elasri, M.
AU - Schippers, J.
AU - Havenith, T. R. A.
AU - van Loo, M.
AU - van Vonderen, M. G. A.
AU - Kampschreur, L. M.
AU - van Broekhuizen, M. C.
AU - S, null
AU - Faber, null
AU - Al Moujahid, A.
AU - Kootstra, G. J.
AU - Delsing, C. E.
AU - van der Burg-van de Plas, M.
AU - Scheiberlich, L.
AU - Kortmann, W.
AU - van Twillert, G.
AU - Renckens, R.
AU - Wagenaar, J.
AU - Ruiter-Pronk, D.
AU - van Truijen-Oud, F. A.
AU - Stuart, J. W. T. Cohen
AU - Hoogewerf, M.
AU - Rozemeijer, W.
AU - Sinnige, J. C.
AU - Brinkman, K.
AU - van den Berk, G. E. L.
AU - Lettinga, K. D.
AU - de Regt, M.
AU - Schouten, W. E. M.
AU - Stalenhoef, J. E.
AU - Veenstra, J.
AU - Vrouenraets, S. M. E.
AU - Blaauw, H.
AU - Geerders, G. F.
AU - Kleene, M. J.
AU - Knapen, M.
AU - Kok, M.
AU - van der Meché, I. B.
AU - Toonen, A. J. M.
AU - Wijnands, S.
AU - Wttewaal, E.
AU - Kwa, D.
AU - van de Laar, T. J. W.
AU - van Crevel, R.
AU - van Aerde, K.
AU - Dofferhoff, A. S. M.
AU - Henriet, S. S. V.
AU - Hofstede, H. J. M. ter
AU - Hoogerwerf, J.
AU - Richel, O.
AU - Albers, M.
AU - Grintjes-Huisman, K. J. T.
AU - de Haan, M.
AU - Marneef, M.
AU - McCall, M.
AU - Burger, D.
AU - Gisolf, E. H.
AU - Claassen, M.
AU - Hassing, R. J.
AU - Beest, G. ter
AU - van Bentum, P. H. M.
AU - Gelling, M.
AU - Neijland, Y.
AU - Swanink, C. M. A.
AU - Velderman, M. Klein
AU - van Lelyveld, S. F. L.
AU - Soetekouw, R.
AU - van der Prijt, L. M. M.
AU - van der Swaluw, J.
AU - Kalpoe, J. S.
AU - Wagemakers, A.
AU - Vahidnia, A.
AU - Lauw, F. N.
AU - Verhagen, D. W. M.
AU - van Wijk, M.
AU - Bierman, W. F. W.
AU - Bakker, M.
AU - van Bentum, R. A.
AU - van den Boomgaard, M. A.
AU - Kleinnijenhuis, J.
AU - Kloeze, E.
AU - Middel, A.
AU - Postma, D. F.
AU - Schenk, H. M.
AU - Stienstra, Y.
AU - Wouthuyzen-Bakker, M.
AU - Boonstra, A.
AU - de Jonge, H.
AU - Maerman, M. M. M.
AU - de Weerd, D. A.
AU - van Eije, K. J.
AU - Knoester, M.
AU - van Leer-Buter, C. C.
AU - Niesters, H. G. M.
AU - t.Mudrikova, null
AU - Barth, R. E.
AU - Bruns, A. H. W.
AU - Ellerbroek, P. M.
AU - Hensgens, M. P. M.
AU - Oosterheert, J. J.
AU - Schadd, E. M.
AU - Verbon, A.
AU - van Welzen, B. J.
AU - Berends, H.
AU - Santen, B. M. G. Griffioen-van
AU - de Kroon, I.
AU - Lunel, F. M. Verduyn
AU - Wensing, A. M. J.
AU - Zaheri, S.
AU - Boyd, A. C.
AU - Bezemer, D. O.
AU - van Sighem, A. I.
AU - Smit, C.
AU - Hillebregt, M. M. J.
AU - Woudstra, T. J.
AU - Rutkens, T.
AU - Bergsma, D.
AU - Brétin, N. M.
AU - Lelivelt, K. J.
AU - van de Sande, L.
AU - van der Vliet, K. M. Visser.S. T.
AU - Paling, F.
AU - de Groot-Berndsen, L. G. M.
AU - van den Akker, M.
AU - Alexander, R.
AU - Bakker, Y.
AU - el Berkaoui, A.
AU - Bezemer-Goedhart, M.
AU - Djoechro, E. A.
AU - Groters, M.
AU - Koster, L. E.
AU - Lodewijk, C. R. E.
AU - Lucas, E. G. A.
AU - Munjishvili, L.
AU - Peeck, B. M.
AU - Ree, C. M. J.
AU - Regtop, R.
AU - van Rijk, A. F.
AU - Ruijs-Tiggelman, Y. M. C.
AU - Schnörr, P. P.
AU - Schoorl, M. J. C.
AU - Tuijn, E. M.
AU - Veenenberg, D. P.
AU - Witte, E. C. M.
AU - Bretin, N. M.
AU - Karpov, I.
AU - Losso, M.
AU - Lundgren, J.
AU - Rockstroh, J.
AU - Aho, I.
AU - Rasmussen, L. D.
AU - Novak, P.
AU - Pradier, C.
AU - Chkhartishvili, N.
AU - Matulionyte, R.
AU - Oprea, C.
AU - Kowalska, J. D.
AU - Begovac, J.
AU - Miró, J. M.
AU - Guaraldi, G.
AU - Paredes, R.
AU - Peters, L.
AU - Larsen, J. F.
AU - Neesgaard, B.
AU - Jaschinski, N.
AU - Fursa, O.
AU - Raben, D.
AU - Kristensen, D.
AU - Fischer, A. H.
AU - Jensen, S. K.
AU - Elsing, T. W.
AU - Gardizi, M.
AU - Mocroft, A.
AU - Phillips, A.
AU - Reekie, J.
AU - Cozzi-Lepri, A.
AU - Pelchen-Matthews, A.
AU - Roen, A.
AU - Tusch, E. S.
AU - Bannister, W.
AU - ANRS CO3 Aquitaine Cohort
AU - Bellecave, P.
AU - Blanco, P.
AU - Bonnet, F.
AU - Bouchet, S.
AU - Breilh, D.
AU - Cazanave, C.
AU - Desjardin, S.
AU - Gaborieau, V.
AU - Gimbert, A.
AU - Hessamfar, M.
AU - Lacaze-Buzy, L.
AU - Lacoste, D.
AU - Lafon, M. E.
AU - Lazaro, E.
AU - Leleux, O.
AU - le Marec, F.
AU - le Moal, G.
AU - Malvy, D.
AU - Marchand, L.
AU - Mercié, P.
AU - Neau, D.
AU - Pellegrin, I.
AU - Perrier, A.
AU - Petrov-Sanchez, V.
AU - Vareil, M. O.
AU - Wittkop, L.
AU - Bernard, N.
AU - Chaussade, D. Bronnimann H.
AU - Dondia, D.
AU - Duffau, P.
AU - Faure, I.
AU - Morlat, P.
AU - Mériglier, E.
AU - Paccalin, F.
AU - Riebero, E.
AU - Rivoisy, C.
AU - Vandenhende, M. A.
AU - Barthod, L.
AU - Dauchy, F. A.
AU - Desclaux, A.
AU - Ducours, M.
AU - Dutronc, H.
AU - Duvignaud, A.
AU - Leitao, J.
AU - Lescure, M.
AU - Nguyen, D.
AU - Pistone, T.
AU - Puges, M.
AU - Wirth, G.
AU - Courtault, C.
AU - Camou, F.
AU - Greib, C.
AU - Pellegrin, J. L.
AU - Rivière, E.
AU - Viallard, J. F.
AU - Imbert, Y.
AU - Thierry-Mieg, M.
AU - Rispal, P.
AU - Caubet, O.
AU - Ferrand, H.
AU - Tchamgoué, S.
AU - Farbos, S.
AU - Wille, H.
AU - Andre, K.
AU - Caunegre, L.
AU - Gerard, Y.
AU - Osorio-Perez, F.
AU - Chossat, I.
AU - Iles, G.
AU - Labasse-Depis, M.
AU - Lacassin, F.
AU - Barret, A.
AU - Castan, B.
AU - Koffi, J.
AU - Rouanes, N.
AU - Saunier, A.
AU - Zabbe, J. B.
AU - Dumondin, G.
AU - Beraud, G.
AU - Catroux, M.
AU - Garcia, M.
AU - Giraud, V.
AU - Martellosio, J. P.
AU - Roblot, F.
AU - Pasdeloup, T.
AU - Riché, A.
AU - Grosset, M.
AU - Males, S.
AU - Bell, C. Ngo
AU - Carpentier, C.
AU - Bellecave, Virology P.
AU - Tumiotto, C.
AU - Miremeont-Salamé, G.
AU - Arma, D.
AU - Arnou, G.
AU - Blaizeau, M. J.
AU - Camps, P.
AU - Decoin, M.
AU - Delveaux, S.
AU - Diarra, F.
AU - Gabrea, L.
AU - Lawson-Ayayi, S.
AU - Lenaud, E.
AU - Plainchamps, D.
AU - Pougetoux, A.
AU - Uwamaliya, B.
AU - Zara, K.
AU - Conte, V.
AU - Gapillout, M.
N1 - Publisher Copyright: © 2023 The Author(s)
PY - 2023/5
Y1 - 2023/5
N2 - Background & Aims: HBV coinfection is common among people living with HIV (PLWH) and is the most important cause of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). While risk prediction tools for HCC have been validated in patients with HBV monoinfection, they have not been evaluated in PLWH. Thus, we performed an external validation of PAGE-B in people with HIV/HBV coinfection. Methods: We included data on PLWH from four European cohorts who were positive for HBsAg and did not have HCC before starting tenofovir. We estimated the predictive performance of PAGE-B for HCC occurrence over 15 years in patients receiving tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy. Model discrimination was assessed after multiple imputation using Cox regression with the prognostic index as a covariate, and by calculating Harrell's c-index. Calibration was assessed by comparing our cumulative incidence with the PAGE-B derivation study using Kaplan-Meier curves. Results: In total, 2,963 individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection on tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy were included. PAGE-B was <10 in 26.5%, 10–17 in 57.7%, and ≥18 in 15.7% of patients. Within a median follow-up of 9.6 years, HCC occurred in 68 individuals (2.58/1,000 patient-years, 95% CI 2.03–3.27). The regression slope of the prognostic index for developing HCC within 15 years was 0.93 (95% CI 0.61–1.25), and the pooled c-index was 0.77 (range 0.73–0.80), both indicating good model discrimination. The cumulative incidence of HCC was lower in our study compared to the derivation study. A PAGE-B cut-off of <10 had a negative predictive value of 99.4% for the development of HCC within 5 years. Restricting efforts to individuals with a PAGE-B of ≥10 would spare unnecessary HCC screening in 27% of individuals. Conclusions: For individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection, PAGE-B is a valid tool to determine the need for HCC screening. Impact and implications: Chronic HBV infection is the most important cause of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) among people living with HIV. Valid risk prediction may enable better targeting of HCC screening efforts to high-risk individuals. We aimed to validate PAGE-B, a risk prediction tool that is based on age, sex, and platelets, in 2,963 individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection who received tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy. In the present study, PAGE-B showed good discrimination, adequate calibration, and a cut-off of <10 had a negative predictive value of 99.4% for the development of HCC within 5 years. These results indicate that PAGE-B is a simple and valid risk prediction tool to determine the need for HCC screening among people living with HIV and HBV.
AB - Background & Aims: HBV coinfection is common among people living with HIV (PLWH) and is the most important cause of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). While risk prediction tools for HCC have been validated in patients with HBV monoinfection, they have not been evaluated in PLWH. Thus, we performed an external validation of PAGE-B in people with HIV/HBV coinfection. Methods: We included data on PLWH from four European cohorts who were positive for HBsAg and did not have HCC before starting tenofovir. We estimated the predictive performance of PAGE-B for HCC occurrence over 15 years in patients receiving tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy. Model discrimination was assessed after multiple imputation using Cox regression with the prognostic index as a covariate, and by calculating Harrell's c-index. Calibration was assessed by comparing our cumulative incidence with the PAGE-B derivation study using Kaplan-Meier curves. Results: In total, 2,963 individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection on tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy were included. PAGE-B was <10 in 26.5%, 10–17 in 57.7%, and ≥18 in 15.7% of patients. Within a median follow-up of 9.6 years, HCC occurred in 68 individuals (2.58/1,000 patient-years, 95% CI 2.03–3.27). The regression slope of the prognostic index for developing HCC within 15 years was 0.93 (95% CI 0.61–1.25), and the pooled c-index was 0.77 (range 0.73–0.80), both indicating good model discrimination. The cumulative incidence of HCC was lower in our study compared to the derivation study. A PAGE-B cut-off of <10 had a negative predictive value of 99.4% for the development of HCC within 5 years. Restricting efforts to individuals with a PAGE-B of ≥10 would spare unnecessary HCC screening in 27% of individuals. Conclusions: For individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection, PAGE-B is a valid tool to determine the need for HCC screening. Impact and implications: Chronic HBV infection is the most important cause of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) among people living with HIV. Valid risk prediction may enable better targeting of HCC screening efforts to high-risk individuals. We aimed to validate PAGE-B, a risk prediction tool that is based on age, sex, and platelets, in 2,963 individuals with HIV/HBV coinfection who received tenofovir-containing antiretroviral therapy. In the present study, PAGE-B showed good discrimination, adequate calibration, and a cut-off of <10 had a negative predictive value of 99.4% for the development of HCC within 5 years. These results indicate that PAGE-B is a simple and valid risk prediction tool to determine the need for HCC screening among people living with HIV and HBV.
KW - Hepatitis B virus
KW - hepatocellular carcinoma
KW - HIV infection
KW - liver cirrhosis
KW - liver neoplasms
KW - model validation
KW - risk assessment
KW - risk prediction models
KW - tenofovir
UR - https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?partnerID=HzOxMe3b&scp=85149981246&origin=inward
UR - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36690280
U2 - 10.1016/j.jhep.2022.12.029
DO - 10.1016/j.jhep.2022.12.029
M3 - Article
C2 - 36690280
SN - 0168-8278
VL - 78
SP - 947
EP - 957
JO - Journal of Hepatology
JF - Journal of Hepatology
IS - 5
ER -