'Oh my God, I can't handle this!': trainees' emotional responses to complex situations

Esther Helmich, Laura Diachun, Radha Joseph, Kori LaDonna, Nelleke Noeverman-Poel, Lorelei Lingard, Sayra Cristancho

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

CONTEXT: Dealing with emotions is critical for medical trainees' professional development. Taking a sociocultural and narrative approach to understanding emotions, we studied complex clinical situations as a specific context in which emotions are evoked and influenced by the social environment. We sought to understand how medical trainees respond to emotions that arise in those situations.

METHODS: In an international constructivist grounded theory study, 29 trainees drew two rich pictures of complex clinical situations, one exciting and one frustrating. Rich pictures are visual representations that capture participants' perceptions about the people, situations and factors that create clinical complexity. These pictures were used to guide semi-structured, individual interviews. We analysed visual materials and interviews in an integrated way, starting with looking at the drawings, doing a 'gallery walk', and using the interviews to inform the aesthetic analysis.

RESULTS: Participants' drawings depicted a range of personal emotions in response to complexity, and disclosed unsettling feelings and behaviours that might be considered unprofessional. When trainees felt confident, they were actively participating, engaged in creative problem-solving strategies, and emphasised their personal involvement. When trainees felt the situation was beyond their control, they described how they were running away from the situation, hiding themselves behind others or distancing themselves from patients or families.

CONCLUSIONS: A sense of control seems to be a key factor influencing trainees' emotional and behavioural responses to complexity. This is problematic, as complex situations are by their nature emergent and dynamic, which limits possibilities for control. Following a social performative approach to emotions, we should help students understand that feeling out of control is an inherent property of participating in complex clinical situations, and, by extension, that it is not something they will 'grow out of' with expertise.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)206-215
Number of pages10
JournalMedical Education
Volume52
Issue number2
Early online date16 Oct 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Feb 2018

Cite this

Helmich, E., Diachun, L., Joseph, R., LaDonna, K., Noeverman-Poel, N., Lingard, L., & Cristancho, S. (2018). 'Oh my God, I can't handle this!': trainees' emotional responses to complex situations. Medical Education, 52(2), 206-215. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.13472
Helmich, Esther ; Diachun, Laura ; Joseph, Radha ; LaDonna, Kori ; Noeverman-Poel, Nelleke ; Lingard, Lorelei ; Cristancho, Sayra. / 'Oh my God, I can't handle this!' : trainees' emotional responses to complex situations. In: Medical Education. 2018 ; Vol. 52, No. 2. pp. 206-215.
@article{9495e20dc701446a91ffcee94f056b51,
title = "'Oh my God, I can't handle this!': trainees' emotional responses to complex situations",
abstract = "CONTEXT: Dealing with emotions is critical for medical trainees' professional development. Taking a sociocultural and narrative approach to understanding emotions, we studied complex clinical situations as a specific context in which emotions are evoked and influenced by the social environment. We sought to understand how medical trainees respond to emotions that arise in those situations.METHODS: In an international constructivist grounded theory study, 29 trainees drew two rich pictures of complex clinical situations, one exciting and one frustrating. Rich pictures are visual representations that capture participants' perceptions about the people, situations and factors that create clinical complexity. These pictures were used to guide semi-structured, individual interviews. We analysed visual materials and interviews in an integrated way, starting with looking at the drawings, doing a 'gallery walk', and using the interviews to inform the aesthetic analysis.RESULTS: Participants' drawings depicted a range of personal emotions in response to complexity, and disclosed unsettling feelings and behaviours that might be considered unprofessional. When trainees felt confident, they were actively participating, engaged in creative problem-solving strategies, and emphasised their personal involvement. When trainees felt the situation was beyond their control, they described how they were running away from the situation, hiding themselves behind others or distancing themselves from patients or families.CONCLUSIONS: A sense of control seems to be a key factor influencing trainees' emotional and behavioural responses to complexity. This is problematic, as complex situations are by their nature emergent and dynamic, which limits possibilities for control. Following a social performative approach to emotions, we should help students understand that feeling out of control is an inherent property of participating in complex clinical situations, and, by extension, that it is not something they will 'grow out of' with expertise.",
keywords = "Journal Article",
author = "Esther Helmich and Laura Diachun and Radha Joseph and Kori LaDonna and Nelleke Noeverman-Poel and Lorelei Lingard and Sayra Cristancho",
note = "{\circledC} 2017 John Wiley & Sons Ltd and The Association for the Study of Medical Education.",
year = "2018",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/medu.13472",
language = "English",
volume = "52",
pages = "206--215",
journal = "Medical Education",
issn = "0308-0110",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "2",

}

Helmich, E, Diachun, L, Joseph, R, LaDonna, K, Noeverman-Poel, N, Lingard, L & Cristancho, S 2018, ''Oh my God, I can't handle this!': trainees' emotional responses to complex situations' Medical Education, vol. 52, no. 2, pp. 206-215. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.13472

'Oh my God, I can't handle this!' : trainees' emotional responses to complex situations. / Helmich, Esther; Diachun, Laura; Joseph, Radha; LaDonna, Kori; Noeverman-Poel, Nelleke; Lingard, Lorelei; Cristancho, Sayra.

In: Medical Education, Vol. 52, No. 2, 01.02.2018, p. 206-215.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'Oh my God, I can't handle this!'

T2 - trainees' emotional responses to complex situations

AU - Helmich, Esther

AU - Diachun, Laura

AU - Joseph, Radha

AU - LaDonna, Kori

AU - Noeverman-Poel, Nelleke

AU - Lingard, Lorelei

AU - Cristancho, Sayra

N1 - © 2017 John Wiley & Sons Ltd and The Association for the Study of Medical Education.

PY - 2018/2/1

Y1 - 2018/2/1

N2 - CONTEXT: Dealing with emotions is critical for medical trainees' professional development. Taking a sociocultural and narrative approach to understanding emotions, we studied complex clinical situations as a specific context in which emotions are evoked and influenced by the social environment. We sought to understand how medical trainees respond to emotions that arise in those situations.METHODS: In an international constructivist grounded theory study, 29 trainees drew two rich pictures of complex clinical situations, one exciting and one frustrating. Rich pictures are visual representations that capture participants' perceptions about the people, situations and factors that create clinical complexity. These pictures were used to guide semi-structured, individual interviews. We analysed visual materials and interviews in an integrated way, starting with looking at the drawings, doing a 'gallery walk', and using the interviews to inform the aesthetic analysis.RESULTS: Participants' drawings depicted a range of personal emotions in response to complexity, and disclosed unsettling feelings and behaviours that might be considered unprofessional. When trainees felt confident, they were actively participating, engaged in creative problem-solving strategies, and emphasised their personal involvement. When trainees felt the situation was beyond their control, they described how they were running away from the situation, hiding themselves behind others or distancing themselves from patients or families.CONCLUSIONS: A sense of control seems to be a key factor influencing trainees' emotional and behavioural responses to complexity. This is problematic, as complex situations are by their nature emergent and dynamic, which limits possibilities for control. Following a social performative approach to emotions, we should help students understand that feeling out of control is an inherent property of participating in complex clinical situations, and, by extension, that it is not something they will 'grow out of' with expertise.

AB - CONTEXT: Dealing with emotions is critical for medical trainees' professional development. Taking a sociocultural and narrative approach to understanding emotions, we studied complex clinical situations as a specific context in which emotions are evoked and influenced by the social environment. We sought to understand how medical trainees respond to emotions that arise in those situations.METHODS: In an international constructivist grounded theory study, 29 trainees drew two rich pictures of complex clinical situations, one exciting and one frustrating. Rich pictures are visual representations that capture participants' perceptions about the people, situations and factors that create clinical complexity. These pictures were used to guide semi-structured, individual interviews. We analysed visual materials and interviews in an integrated way, starting with looking at the drawings, doing a 'gallery walk', and using the interviews to inform the aesthetic analysis.RESULTS: Participants' drawings depicted a range of personal emotions in response to complexity, and disclosed unsettling feelings and behaviours that might be considered unprofessional. When trainees felt confident, they were actively participating, engaged in creative problem-solving strategies, and emphasised their personal involvement. When trainees felt the situation was beyond their control, they described how they were running away from the situation, hiding themselves behind others or distancing themselves from patients or families.CONCLUSIONS: A sense of control seems to be a key factor influencing trainees' emotional and behavioural responses to complexity. This is problematic, as complex situations are by their nature emergent and dynamic, which limits possibilities for control. Following a social performative approach to emotions, we should help students understand that feeling out of control is an inherent property of participating in complex clinical situations, and, by extension, that it is not something they will 'grow out of' with expertise.

KW - Journal Article

U2 - 10.1111/medu.13472

DO - 10.1111/medu.13472

M3 - Article

VL - 52

SP - 206

EP - 215

JO - Medical Education

JF - Medical Education

SN - 0308-0110

IS - 2

ER -