The effectiveness of an experimental treatment when compared to care as usual depends on the type of care as usual

Nicolle M H Van De Wiel, Walter Matthys, Peggy T. Cohen-Kettenis, Gerard H. Maassen, John E. Lochman, Herman Van Engeland

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

In psychotherapy, effectiveness of an experimental treatment often is compared to care as usual. However, little if any attention has been paid to the heterogeneity of care as usual. The authors examined the effectiveness of manualized behavior therapy on school-aged disruptive behavior disordered (DBD) children in everyday clinical practice. A total of 77 DBD children (8-13 years) were randomly assigned to the Utrecht Coping Power Program (UCPP) condition or the care as usual condition. Care as usual consisted of family therapy (FT) or behavior therapy (BT). Decrease in parent-reported overt aggression was significantly larger in the UCPP condition than in the FT condition, but UCPP and BT did not differ significantly in this respect. The effect sizes of difference scores on other variables were more in favor of UCPP when compared to FT than to BT. The comparison of an experimental treatment to care as usual depends on the type of usual treatment.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)298-312
Number of pages15
JournalBehavior Modification
Volume31
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2007

Cite this

Van De Wiel, Nicolle M H ; Matthys, Walter ; Cohen-Kettenis, Peggy T. ; Maassen, Gerard H. ; Lochman, John E. ; Van Engeland, Herman. / The effectiveness of an experimental treatment when compared to care as usual depends on the type of care as usual. In: Behavior Modification. 2007 ; Vol. 31, No. 3. pp. 298-312.
@article{f3c2e3ef1aee46549416ff29eb0c401e,
title = "The effectiveness of an experimental treatment when compared to care as usual depends on the type of care as usual",
abstract = "In psychotherapy, effectiveness of an experimental treatment often is compared to care as usual. However, little if any attention has been paid to the heterogeneity of care as usual. The authors examined the effectiveness of manualized behavior therapy on school-aged disruptive behavior disordered (DBD) children in everyday clinical practice. A total of 77 DBD children (8-13 years) were randomly assigned to the Utrecht Coping Power Program (UCPP) condition or the care as usual condition. Care as usual consisted of family therapy (FT) or behavior therapy (BT). Decrease in parent-reported overt aggression was significantly larger in the UCPP condition than in the FT condition, but UCPP and BT did not differ significantly in this respect. The effect sizes of difference scores on other variables were more in favor of UCPP when compared to FT than to BT. The comparison of an experimental treatment to care as usual depends on the type of usual treatment.",
keywords = "Aggression, Behavior therapy, Child psychotherapy, Disruptive behavior disorder, Methodology",
author = "{Van De Wiel}, {Nicolle M H} and Walter Matthys and Cohen-Kettenis, {Peggy T.} and Maassen, {Gerard H.} and Lochman, {John E.} and {Van Engeland}, Herman",
year = "2007",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/0145445506292855",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "298--312",
journal = "Behavior Modification",
issn = "0145-4455",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "3",

}

The effectiveness of an experimental treatment when compared to care as usual depends on the type of care as usual. / Van De Wiel, Nicolle M H; Matthys, Walter; Cohen-Kettenis, Peggy T.; Maassen, Gerard H.; Lochman, John E.; Van Engeland, Herman.

In: Behavior Modification, Vol. 31, No. 3, 01.05.2007, p. 298-312.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The effectiveness of an experimental treatment when compared to care as usual depends on the type of care as usual

AU - Van De Wiel, Nicolle M H

AU - Matthys, Walter

AU - Cohen-Kettenis, Peggy T.

AU - Maassen, Gerard H.

AU - Lochman, John E.

AU - Van Engeland, Herman

PY - 2007/5/1

Y1 - 2007/5/1

N2 - In psychotherapy, effectiveness of an experimental treatment often is compared to care as usual. However, little if any attention has been paid to the heterogeneity of care as usual. The authors examined the effectiveness of manualized behavior therapy on school-aged disruptive behavior disordered (DBD) children in everyday clinical practice. A total of 77 DBD children (8-13 years) were randomly assigned to the Utrecht Coping Power Program (UCPP) condition or the care as usual condition. Care as usual consisted of family therapy (FT) or behavior therapy (BT). Decrease in parent-reported overt aggression was significantly larger in the UCPP condition than in the FT condition, but UCPP and BT did not differ significantly in this respect. The effect sizes of difference scores on other variables were more in favor of UCPP when compared to FT than to BT. The comparison of an experimental treatment to care as usual depends on the type of usual treatment.

AB - In psychotherapy, effectiveness of an experimental treatment often is compared to care as usual. However, little if any attention has been paid to the heterogeneity of care as usual. The authors examined the effectiveness of manualized behavior therapy on school-aged disruptive behavior disordered (DBD) children in everyday clinical practice. A total of 77 DBD children (8-13 years) were randomly assigned to the Utrecht Coping Power Program (UCPP) condition or the care as usual condition. Care as usual consisted of family therapy (FT) or behavior therapy (BT). Decrease in parent-reported overt aggression was significantly larger in the UCPP condition than in the FT condition, but UCPP and BT did not differ significantly in this respect. The effect sizes of difference scores on other variables were more in favor of UCPP when compared to FT than to BT. The comparison of an experimental treatment to care as usual depends on the type of usual treatment.

KW - Aggression

KW - Behavior therapy

KW - Child psychotherapy

KW - Disruptive behavior disorder

KW - Methodology

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=34247223187&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0145445506292855

DO - 10.1177/0145445506292855

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 298

EP - 312

JO - Behavior Modification

JF - Behavior Modification

SN - 0145-4455

IS - 3

ER -